www.whyville.net Dec 12, 2003 Weekly Issue



madz
Guest Writer

In Defense of Vegetarianism

Users' Rating
Rate this article
 
FRONT PAGE
CREATIVE WRITING
SCIENCE
HOT TOPICS
POLITICS
HEALTH
PANDEMIC

Hello, this is madz here. I am replying to Scroggle2's article titled "Can You Escape the Meat?"

She argued that agriculture is as bad as raising animals for food consumption because animals get indirectly killed in order to plant or replant crops.

In other words, Scroggle2 argued that it is equally as bad to be a vegetarian as a meat-eater because you are still killing animals one way or another.

But I think that indirect killing (e.g. the mowing of an alfalfa field to provide food for vegetarians, in this case) is an entirely different matter than the deliberate raising of animals for slaughter. Eating animals is an act of choice -- we can choose not to do this. Animals being accidentally killed when crops are planted/replanted is an accident and in many cases can be probably avoided if we study the problem long enough. But there is no avoiding the slaughter when you are actually raising animals for meat in the first place.

P.S. And I don't think anyone said that it is right to kill a mouse and not a cow. But I think you will find that most vegetarians don't believe in the killing of any animals unless absolutely necessary -- for example, an introduced pest that is killing and causing the extinction of native animals.

I hope I got my point across. Don't get me wrong, Scroggle2, I think your article was great, as it pointed out another side of the story, but I still think that being a vegetarian is a great idea. Thank you.

 

Did you like this article?
1 Star = Bleh.5 Stars = Props!
Rate it!
Ymail this article to a friend.
Discuss this article in the Forums.

  Back to front page


times@whyville.net
3499